Sweet 16 Update - Oct 2
Posted: Sat Oct 02, 2021 10:29 am
September was the best month ever for the Sweet 16. The portfolio gained over 50% from Sept 1 to Oct 1. This compares to the S&P 500 Index that lost 2.7% during the same period. This indicates a SIGNIFICANT amount of rotation into the Energy Sector.
For the week ending October 1 the Sweet 16 gained 12.89%, while the S&P 500 Index lost 2.62%.
Year-to-date the Sweet 16 is up 149.37%, while the S&P 500 Index is up 16.00%. This has been a very good year for stocks in general, but I think a lot of investors move cash to the sidelines in October because the month has seen some serious corrections in the past.
Laredo Petroleum (LPI) leads the pack, up 331% YTD and is approaching my valuation of $90.00. LPI is a very High Beta stock, so it may be time to harvest this gain. However, my valuation is based on a very low multiple of operating cash flow per share, which I forecast to be $29.20 in 2021 and $39.78 in 2022. If Laredo's Q3 results and updated guidance confirm my forecast production assumptions my valuation may go as high as $130.00. Laredo has only 17 million shares outstanding, which is very low for a company of this size. I am expecting their production guidance to point to a 2021 exit rate of more than 80,000 Boepd.
CPE (up 283%), AR (up 252%) and RRC (up 244%) round out the "Final Four" to stick with my NCAA basketball comparison for the portfolio. In case you are wondering, when EPG was founded in 2001 by Kevin Hopkins, we set up the first ever EPG model portfolio during March Madness. I took over EPG 100% in 2006. Time flies when you are having fun.
The "worst" preforming stock in the portfolio is Pioneer Natural Resources (PXD), up 53.4% YTD. It has been a Wall Street favorite for years and was not grossly oversold in 2020 like most of the others. My current valuation of $249/share is likely to go up after the release Q3 results.
Overall, the Sweet 16 closed on October 1 at a 52.6% discount to my current valuation. As Goldman Sachs confirmed in their updated oil price forecast yesterday, the Wall Street Gang is still valuing upstream companies based on $60/bbl WTI and $2.50/mcf HH natural gas prices. Goldman Sachs' top three picks are PXD, DVN and FANG. To a lesser extent they rate EQT, OVV, PDCE and MGY (in our Small-Cap Growth Portfolio) as BUYs. < If you would like to read the GS report (13 pages) just send me an email and I will forward it to you: dmsteffens@comcast.net
PDC Energy (PDCE) released an operations update which was mildly disappointing sighting lower than expected well results in the Permian Basin. IMO the market (as it usually does) overreacted on Friday. I have adjusted my forecast to their new guidance and I also lowered my 2022 production estimates and all it did was lower my valuation by $2 to $80. Most of PDC's production comes from the DJ Basin in Colorado and the Wall Street Gang considers that state to have "Geopolitical Risk". Colorado gets a lot of tax revenues from the oil & gas industry, so I believe that risk is minimal.
Comstock Resources (CRK) has gained close to 50% since the beginning of September but it still trades at less than half of my current valuation of $21.00. Comstock is a pure gasser that holds some extremely valuable leasehold in the Haynesville Shale play; over 1,900 low-risk / high-return horizontal drilling locations. This company is controlled by Jerry Jones.
AR and EQT are still trading at less than book value, which IMO is "insane" considering the BIG IMPROVEMENT in natural gas and NGL prices. These two and RRC are going to harvest some very big spot market premiums this winter because the Northeast (thanks to idiot leadership) are going to be short natural gas and begging for more home heating fuels this winter.
Earthstone Energy (ESTE) and Ovintiv (OVV) are also trading at a deep discount to my valuations.
Cimarex Energy (XEC) will be officially merging into Cabot Oil & Gas (COG) next week. The combined company will be renamed and start trading on Monday, October 4 at Coterra Energy Inc. (NYSE: COG). < This large-cap "gasser" will draw a lot of Wall Street's attention. My initial valuation is $29.00. See post below.
For the week ending October 1 the Sweet 16 gained 12.89%, while the S&P 500 Index lost 2.62%.
Year-to-date the Sweet 16 is up 149.37%, while the S&P 500 Index is up 16.00%. This has been a very good year for stocks in general, but I think a lot of investors move cash to the sidelines in October because the month has seen some serious corrections in the past.
Laredo Petroleum (LPI) leads the pack, up 331% YTD and is approaching my valuation of $90.00. LPI is a very High Beta stock, so it may be time to harvest this gain. However, my valuation is based on a very low multiple of operating cash flow per share, which I forecast to be $29.20 in 2021 and $39.78 in 2022. If Laredo's Q3 results and updated guidance confirm my forecast production assumptions my valuation may go as high as $130.00. Laredo has only 17 million shares outstanding, which is very low for a company of this size. I am expecting their production guidance to point to a 2021 exit rate of more than 80,000 Boepd.
CPE (up 283%), AR (up 252%) and RRC (up 244%) round out the "Final Four" to stick with my NCAA basketball comparison for the portfolio. In case you are wondering, when EPG was founded in 2001 by Kevin Hopkins, we set up the first ever EPG model portfolio during March Madness. I took over EPG 100% in 2006. Time flies when you are having fun.
The "worst" preforming stock in the portfolio is Pioneer Natural Resources (PXD), up 53.4% YTD. It has been a Wall Street favorite for years and was not grossly oversold in 2020 like most of the others. My current valuation of $249/share is likely to go up after the release Q3 results.
Overall, the Sweet 16 closed on October 1 at a 52.6% discount to my current valuation. As Goldman Sachs confirmed in their updated oil price forecast yesterday, the Wall Street Gang is still valuing upstream companies based on $60/bbl WTI and $2.50/mcf HH natural gas prices. Goldman Sachs' top three picks are PXD, DVN and FANG. To a lesser extent they rate EQT, OVV, PDCE and MGY (in our Small-Cap Growth Portfolio) as BUYs. < If you would like to read the GS report (13 pages) just send me an email and I will forward it to you: dmsteffens@comcast.net
PDC Energy (PDCE) released an operations update which was mildly disappointing sighting lower than expected well results in the Permian Basin. IMO the market (as it usually does) overreacted on Friday. I have adjusted my forecast to their new guidance and I also lowered my 2022 production estimates and all it did was lower my valuation by $2 to $80. Most of PDC's production comes from the DJ Basin in Colorado and the Wall Street Gang considers that state to have "Geopolitical Risk". Colorado gets a lot of tax revenues from the oil & gas industry, so I believe that risk is minimal.
Comstock Resources (CRK) has gained close to 50% since the beginning of September but it still trades at less than half of my current valuation of $21.00. Comstock is a pure gasser that holds some extremely valuable leasehold in the Haynesville Shale play; over 1,900 low-risk / high-return horizontal drilling locations. This company is controlled by Jerry Jones.
AR and EQT are still trading at less than book value, which IMO is "insane" considering the BIG IMPROVEMENT in natural gas and NGL prices. These two and RRC are going to harvest some very big spot market premiums this winter because the Northeast (thanks to idiot leadership) are going to be short natural gas and begging for more home heating fuels this winter.
Earthstone Energy (ESTE) and Ovintiv (OVV) are also trading at a deep discount to my valuations.
Cimarex Energy (XEC) will be officially merging into Cabot Oil & Gas (COG) next week. The combined company will be renamed and start trading on Monday, October 4 at Coterra Energy Inc. (NYSE: COG). < This large-cap "gasser" will draw a lot of Wall Street's attention. My initial valuation is $29.00. See post below.